Overall Findings
Because these devices are cheap and easy to use, code readers are convenient for car owners and mechanics who want to read and clear diagnostic codes. Scan tools are more expensive but can do everything a code reader can do, as well as provide troubleshooting tips, data readouts, and diagnostic equipment. Professional automotive technicians typically require high-quality scan tools to work efficiently, while the average do-it-yourselfer should be able to get by with a cheap code reader or a nearby service willing to read codes for free.
Code Readers Pros and Cons
Most people can get by with the free code reading service offered by a local parts store or an internet search to find out what a trouble code means. No two code readers are the same. While feature sets depend largely on price, any code reader can perform the basic task of reading, displaying, clearing codes, and resetting the check engine light in a car. More advanced code readers can do the following:
Display trouble code names.Read and display live data.Display freeze frame data.Display readiness monitor status.Reset readiness monitors.Provide basic access to the full range of parameter IDs (PIDs) provided by a vehicle’s onboard computer.
Scan Tools Pros and Cons
Spending a lot of money on a consumer-grade scan tool makes only sense if you’re a car enthusiast or DIYer with a small fleet of vehicles—not to mention a large budget. Scan tools typically offer a suite of features depending on budget and intended use. Low-end, consumer-grade scan tools provide code definitions and basic troubleshooting tips. High-end scan tools include more in-depth diagnostic and troubleshooting procedures, and some have built-in testing equipment like scopes and multimeters. Here are some of the things a scan tool can do:
Provide troubleshooting information or tips.Record and play back live data.Graph data or graph specific PIDs.Read manufacturer or pending codes.Utilize functions that require bidirectional communication.
Another option to consider is an ELM327 scan tool. These microcontrollers function as an interface between the car’s onboard computer and a personal computer, which could be a smartphone, tablet, or laptop. These devices perform the duties of a basic code reader or an advanced scan tool.
Final Verdict
If you’re wondering whether you should get a code reader or scan tool, start with a code reader. This way, you’ll have the knowledge base without making a big dent in your budget. If you’re a DIY or shade-tree mechanic, a basic code reader can handle the simple task of clearing codes and resetting a check engine light.
